Rigid Vinyl Flooring Comparison

17.04.2025

So, you’ve decided to upgrade your floors, and rigid vinyl flooring is on your radar. Good choice! It’s waterproof, tough as nails, and ridiculously easy to install. But now comes the hard part - picking the right brand.

With so many options out there, how do you know which one’s actually worth your money? Do you go for the thickest, the cheapest, or the one with the fanciest name? And does an integrated underlay really make a difference?

We’re breaking it all down in plain English so you can find the best flooring for your home, without second-guessing your decision.


What is Rigid Vinyl Flooring?

Rigid core vinyl is a modern, high-performance alternative to traditional vinyl and laminate. It is the latest generation of luxury vinyl flooring, and has a reinforced SPC rigid core, which is made from a combination of stone powder and PVC. This creates an ultra-dense core that resists dents, doesn’t expand or contract with temperature changes, and provides a more solid feel underfoot.

How is Rigid Vinyl Flooring Made?

Most rigid core vinyl floors have multiple layers working together to create a floor that’s durable, stylish, and practical:

Layer Purpose
Wear Layer Protects against scratches, stains, and scuffs. The thicker, the better!
Decor Layer High-resolution natural wood or stone effect print for a realistic look.
SPC Rigid Core The game-changer. Made from Stone Polymer Composite (SPC) for strength, waterproofing, and dimensional stability. The stone element within prevents the floor from warping or shifting.
Underlay (Optional) Some brands have built-in underlay for extra soundproofing and comfort. Others require a separate underlay.

How is it Different from Flexible Vinyl?

Unlike flexible vinyl (which can show bumps and imperfections from the subfloor), rigid vinyl flooring has a reinforced core that stays flat and stable. That means it’s perfect for laying over uneven subfloors or covering up old tiles without needing loads of prep work.


Why Choose Rigid Core Flooring?

There’s a reason rigid core vinyl flooring has become a go-to choice for homeowners and businesses alike. It’s built to handle daily wear and tear, resists water, and offers a realistic wood or stone look without the upkeep of organic materials. Here’s what makes it stand out:

1. Unmatched Durability

Designed for high-traffic areas, rigid core vinyl can take heavy footfall, furniture movement, and pet claws without showing signs of wear. The SPC rigid core makes it even tougher, keeping it stable under pressure.

2. 100% Water-resistant

Luxury vinyl tiles won’t swell, warp, or get damaged by moisture. Some brands, such as Karndean, even offer fully waterproof options. It’s an ideal choice for:

  • Kitchen & Dining Room areas
  • Bathrooms
  • Utility rooms
  • Basements

3. Feels Solid & Comfortable Underfoot

Thanks to its solid core and optional integrated underlay, rigid core vinyl provides a stable, cushioned feel underfoot. Some options also include a sound-reducing underlay for a quieter, more comfortable space.

4. DIY-Friendly Installation

Most rigid vinyl floors use a click system, meaning you can install them yourself as a click locking floating floor without glue or nails. Rigid core click vinyl flooring is perfect for home renovations, especially when you're laying floor in a period property with an uneven sub floor. This is different to glue-down LVT which is a more involved process - learn more about the differences in our LVT Click vs Glue-Down guide.

5. Stunning Designs That Look Like Real Wood & Stone

With high-definition printing and embossed textures, today’s luxury vinyl flooring designs are nearly indistinguishable from natural materials. Whether you want the warmth of oak or the elegance of slate, you'll 100% find a design to match your style.


What to Look for When Choosing Rigid Vinyl

Not all flooring is created equal. Some brands focus on affordability, while others offer premium finishes and thicker wear layers for maximum durability. Choosing the right one depends on your budget, style, and, of course, where you plan to install it.

Before choosing, here are some important factors to consider:

  • Core type: SPC vs. WPC – SPC (stone polymer composite) is the industry standard for modern rigid core flooring. It’s denser, more stable, and highly resistant to dents and impacts. WPC (wood polymer composite) is softer underfoot but less common today due to its lower durability.
  • Wear layer thickness – The wear layer is what protects against scratches and scuffs. A 0.3mm wear layer is fine for most residential spaces, while 0.4mm to 0.55mm provides extra protection for high-traffic areas. For commercial spaces, some experts recommend going up to 0.7mm for maximum longevity.
  • Waterproofing – Luxury vinyl flooring is completely waterproof, making it ideal for moisture-prone spaces like kitchens, bathrooms, and basements. Some premium options include a reinforced stone polymer composite layer for additional moisture resistance.
  • Integrated underlay – Some brands come with an underlay built in to reduce noise and improve comfort.
  • Slip resistance and texture – Many luxury vinyl floors have an embossed texture that mimics wood or stone while improving grip. The R-rating system measures slip resistance, ranging from R9 (standard) to R13 (high slip resistance). For areas exposed to frequent moisture, like bathrooms or near patio doors, R11 or higher is recommended.


Which Rigid Vinyl Brand is the Best?

All rigid vinyl flooring is designed to be tough, water resistant, and stylish—but not all brands are created equal. Some focus on affordability, while others go all-in on premium finishes and extra durability. So, how do you choose?

Choosing the right flooring comes down to what matters most to you. A trusted brand offers peace of mind if you need support, while a budget-friendly option balances quality and value. If durability is key, a thicker rigid core adds stability, while even a 0.1mm difference in wear layer can improve long-term resilience. Here's how the top brands compare.

Universal Rigid Click Vinyl – A budget-friendly option that still delivers on durability and water resistance. It features an integrated foam underlay, making it a great DIY-friendly choice while also providing sound insulation.

Moduleo LayRed – A step up in comfort and performance. With a 6mm thickness and built-in underlay, this flooring is ideal for renovation projects, especially over uneven subfloors. It also has excellent acoustic properties, making it perfect for upstairs rooms or open-plan spaces.

Moduleo LayRed Herringbone - The same benefits of Moduleo LayRed, but combined with a variety of stunning herringbone designs.

Karndean Knight Tile Rigid Core -  Karndean's entry-level rigid core vinyl flooring, designed to combine style and practicality at an accessible price point. At 4.5mm thick, it features a built-in acoustic underlay for sound insulation and added comfort underfoot. Known for its highly realistic wood and stone effects, the Knight Tile Rigid Core range delivers a premium look without the premium price.

Karndean Van Gogh Rigid Core - The premium offering in Karndean’s rigid core catalogue, designed for those who want top-tier performance and style. With a robust 6.5mm thickness and a built-in acoustic underlay, it provides superior comfort, sound reduction, and stability. Backed by a lifetime residential warranty, Van Gogh Rigid Core is a long-lasting, high-end flooring solution that doesn’t compromise on looks or durability. 

At the end of the day, the “best” brand is the one that fits your space, your lifestyle, and your budget.

 


Side-by-Side Brand Comparison

Feature Universal Rigid Click Moduleo LayRed Moduleo LayRed Herringbone Karndean Knight Tile Karndean Van Gogh
Thickness 5.5mm 6mm 6mm 4.5mm 6.5mm
Wear Layer 0.3mm 0.55mm 0.55mm 0.3mm 0.55mm
Usage Class (Residential) 23 (Heavy) 23 (Heavy) 23 (Heavy) 23 (Heavy) 23 (Heavy)
Guarantee (Residential) Lifetime Lifetime Lifetime Lifetime Lifetime
Usage Class (Commercial) 31 (Moderate) 32 (General) 32 (General) 31 (Moderate) 33 (Heavy)
Guarantee (Commercial) 10 Years 10 Years 10 Years 10 Years 15 Years
Water Resistance Water Resistant Waterproof Waterproof Waterproof Waterproof
Slip Resistance R10 R10 R10 R10 R10
Price Per m2 (April 2025) £23.99 £45.49 £47.49 £40.99 £53.95

Final Thoughts: Which Floor is Right for You?

At the end of the day, the best flooring is the one that fits your home, your budget, and your priorities.

  • If you’re looking for the most affordable option that still gets the job done, Universal Click is a solid pick. It’s durable, waterproof, and won’t break the bank - plus, clearance deals can make it even better value.
  • If you want something thicker and more cushioned underfoot, Moduleo LayRed is an excellent choice. It’s got an underlay for extra comfort and noise reduction, making it perfect for bedrooms, upstairs spaces, or anywhere you want a little more luxury.

Whatever you choose, don’t just rely on specs and comparison charts—order some samples and see for yourself. Nothing beats getting the actual flooring in your hands to check the quality, texture, and colour in your own space. Shop all Rigid Core Vinyl and start your flooring transformation!

Related Posts

Related Products
88f6096788791901d98f78972f6274a567cc13567ad64fbe0d123a5b62dbc9a3 3.148.233.239